Case contributed by:

Mark J. Berber, MD, FRCP(C), MRCPsych, MRCGP
Director, Outpatient Mental Health Services
Markham Stouffville Hospital
Lecturer, Department of Psychiatry
University of Toronto

After completion of this case, participants will be able to:

  • Clarify the nature of the mood disorder
  • Appropriately manage an inadequate response to treatment
  • Effectively optimize an antidepressant trial
  • Evaluate the need for long-term therapy.

Patient Presentation:
Ms. T. is a 42-year-old bank teller who lives with her husband, an accountant, and their two teenaged children. Ms. T. has been a patient of yours for many years, but you have not seen her for a long time. It is early December and Ms. T. tells you that she has been feeling down for at least two months. Initially, she thought that she would "snap out of it", but her mood has been deteriorating steadily. A recent vacation with her husband did not go well, especially because of her low libido. Ms. T. continues by saying that she has recently been unable to derive pleasure from any activity. Without prompting, she states that she feels tired all the time and has lost her usual joie de vivre. She blames this fatigue on a restless sleep pattern, saying that it takes her several hours to fall asleep, and that she feels "wrecked" in the morning. Poor concentration and feelings of agitation are making it difficult for her to function at work, and Ms. T. tells you that she feels worthless as an employee and as a wife and mother.

Questions to Consider:

  • What further information would you like to obtain from Ms. T.?

Gathering further history, you learn that Ms. T.’s mother was recently diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease, although the family physician had reassured her that it was mild. Further functional inquiry reveals that this recent episode of depression was insidious in onset, with gradual worsening over the past year. Ms. T. is not currently experiencing suicidal ideation. Woven into her dysphoria are anxiety, apprehension and tension with muscle aches and pains. She does not experience panic attacks, phobias, obsessions or compulsions and does not endorse a current or past history of mania, hypomania, delusions or hallucinations. Two months ago, she missed a couple of days at work because of "stress". Ms. T. reports healthy interpersonal relations, naming her husband as her primary support. Sexual relations prior to the onset of this depressive episode were mutually satisfying. Her medical history is unremarkable and menstrual cycles are normal. There is no personal history of seasonal mood episodes and no family history of any psychiatric illnesses.

Questions to Consider:

  • After this initial history, what is your working diagnosis and what is your differential diagnosis?
  • What investigations would you consider at this point?
  • How would you monitor depressive symptoms (i.e., how would you detect changes in response to treatment?)
  • How would you determine the patient’s functioning at home and in her job setting?
  • How would you predict her return date if she were off work?

You diagnose major depression of moderate severity and determine that there is no comorbid condition. You discuss treatment options with Ms. T., who expresses to you her urgent wish to return to feeling well as soon as possible. You select venlafaxine XR 75 mg daily and discuss the possible side effects that may occur with this antidepressant. You inform Ms. T. that her baseline bloodwork was normal.

Questions to Consider:

  • At what point in the treatment of depression are the chances of achieving full remission with an antidepressant at their greatest?
  • What is the usual effective dose of venlafaxine in outpatients with depression?
  • What is the maximum dose of venlafaxine? What is the evidence for a steep dose-response curve with this agent?

You reassure Ms. T. that antidepressants are not addictive and will not change her personality. You advise her that the antidepressant effects are not instantaneous and that it may take three to six weeks before full antidepressant effects are seen. You arrange a follow-up appointment for two weeks hence, but ask Ms. T. to telephone your office earlier should her condition deteriorate or should side effects cause distress.

Ms. T. returns two weeks later stating she has been fully compliant with her medication. She noticed a slight improvement in her mood, but still feels quite depressed. She had mild nausea at the start of treatment but this side effect did not persist beyond the first week of therapy.

Question to Consider:

  • What would be your course of action at this stage?

Ms. T. is advised to increase the dose of venlafaxine XR to 150 mg daily. As you are keen to achieve full remission and promote recovery, you arrange an appointment to see her again in two weeks. At that time, she returns to see you, looking much better. She tells you that there has been a marked improvement in her mood since the dose of venlafaxine XR was raised. Sleep, energy level, concentration, self-esteem and libido have all improved and Ms. T. expresses her wish to return to teaching. You recommend that she continue to take venlafaxine XR 150 mg daily and ask that she return in four weeks to monitor her progress. At this next follow-up appointment, Ms. T. tells you that she feels great, fully back to her former happy self.

Questions to Consider:

  • How long should Ms. T. remain on venlafaxine?
  • If Ms. T. had returned to see you after a six-week course of venlafaxine XR 150 mg qam and complained of persistent residual depressive symptoms, how would you respond?

Discussion:
The goals of antidepressant treatment are to eliminate completely the symptoms and signs of depression, to restore occupational and psychosocial functioning and to prevent relapse or recurrence. Residual symptoms (partial remission) occur in up to one third of treated depressed individuals and portend a liability to relapse and recurrence. Longitudinal studies of depressed patients have revealed that the best chance for achieving remission may occur within six months of the onset of treatment. Psychiatrists often see patients well after this window of opportunity has closed. Therefore, the primary care provider is in a unique position to enhance successful treatment outcomes.

Undertreatment is a common cause of chronic depression. There are many reasons for undertreatment, including unawareness of optimal therapeutic dosing, selection of inadequate antidepressants, inadequate dose, inadequate duration, concerns about safety and side-effects. It usually requires several weeks to observe clinically significant effects with antidepressants. Unfortunately, the side effects occur early, and often lead to discontinuation of treatment. Patient education regarding adverse events and time course to response is essential in order to increase compliance and acceptance of transient adverse events. Patients with comorbid conditions and those who have difficulty metabolizing psychotropic agents (e.g. older or medically compromised patients) are more often sensitive to drug-related adverse events. In these situations, the clinician should begin at the lowest possible dose, and titrate upward slowly.

If a fully compliant patient has no antidepressant response after six weeks on an adequate dose of medication, a new antidepressant strategy should be considered. If there is partial remission, the clinician should consider optimization to the highest tolerated dose: dose optimization is critical in antidepressant therapy.

The majority of depressive patients are undertreated, and up to half will discontinue their antidepressant within about three months. Inadequate optimization of any antidepressant increases the risk of residual symptoms which, in turn, heightens the risk of relapse, recurrence and chronicity.

Once the patient achieves remission, continuation treatment lasting six to nine months is generally recommended in order to prevent relapse. The goal of maintenance therapy is to ensure continued recovery; maintenance therapy should always be considered in those patients who are at higher risk of recurrence. Discontinuation of the antidepressant medication should be gradual in order to avoid a discontinuation syndrome.

Proceed to Section IV - "Clinical Cases - Case #2"